Showing posts with label undeserved oscars. Show all posts
Showing posts with label undeserved oscars. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

You MUST give back that Oscar! It's a wrap....


Well, I've given you my "top five" choices for the most unjustly- awarded Academy Awards in Oscar history.  Narrowing the list down to just five choices was certainly a challenge, as there are so many worthy (or is it "unworthy"?) others.  So I thought we'd have a brief wrap-up of a few other choices that might be considered prime candidates for the "honors".  I expect this year that we may have a few more contenders, too!  See you on Sunday, February 27!  I'll be "live-blogging" during the show, if you care to join me...hope to see you here!:

And they are, in no particular order:




Best Actress, 1998:  Gwyneth Paltrow in Shakespeare in Love.  It's become almost an accepted fact that most people, for one reason or another, simply can't stand her.  Whether it's for her on-screen or her off-screen persona--or perhaps a little bit of both--is hard to tell.  Hers was selected over Cate Blanchett's incandescent performance in Elizabeth.  Fourteen years ago, the Gwyneth-bashing hadn't really begun yet in full.  Could her Oscar-win have been the springboard?  Who knows.  Her performance wasn't bad--merely a bit of fluff in which she played the "pants-role" (disguised as a man) as well as the female love interest of Joseph Fiennes (whatever happened to him?). It was a clever-enough film, but rather instantly forgettable.  And Paltrow?  She was...good-ish.  But "Best Actress"?  Over Cate Blanchett?  WRONG CHOICE, FOLKS!  The Oscar REALLY goes to: 
Cate Blanchett for Elizabeth

Best Supporting Actress, 1998: Judi Dench in Shakespeare in Love.  We all love Dame Judi Dench. She never fails to steal every scene she's in, including her very few scenes Shakespeare in Love, in which she has what amounts to a cameo role as Queen Elizabeth I.  Her performance, in total, amounts to less than 8 minutes of screen time.  Clearly her win for this miniscule part was a sop for having lost the previous year for Mrs. Brown (to Helen Hunt....grrr.... see part 3).  Since the "Best Supporting" awards are so often given for reasons other than the winning performance itself (overall career achievement, encouragement of a new performer, etc.), the award should have been given to a wonderful actress, much overshadowed by her loudmouth sister, who gave a touching and skilled performance that year--and had never won an Oscar (and, sadly, never would). 
And the Oscar REALLY goes to: 

Lynn Redgrave for Gods and Monsters.





Best Supporting Actor 1997: Robin Williams in Good Will Hunting.  With the possible exception of Dead Poet's Society, I've never seen Robin Williams in a dramatic film where I found his characterization believable, including this one.  He comes across as either strait-jacketed or medicated.  He's a brilliant comedian.  Oscar-worthy dramatic actor?  Not in my book.  And the Oscar REALLY goes to: 

Anthony Hopkins in Amistad.



Best Supporting Actress, 1995:  Mira Sorvino,  Mighty Aphrodite.  There has long been an Academy tradition of handing this award to new, young actresses, as sort of a "welcome" to the industry.  Some (Meryl Streep, Kramer vs. Kramer; Jessica Lange, Tootsie) went on to fulfill the voters' "show of faith" and proved their Oscar worthiness in a long series of other fine performances.  Others (Miyoshi Umeki, Sayonara; Marlee Matlin, Children of a Lesser God; Tatum O'Neal, Paper Moon) watched their careers fizzle almost as soon as the Oscar hit the mantle.  Perhaps most emblematic of that sub-category of "Best Supporting Actress" winners is Mira Sorvino--a selection that continues to baffle Oscar historians.  It's not that she was "bad," per se...but how can one say that her cartoonish portrayal of a nasal, brain-dead hooker (in one of Woody Allen's most forgettable films) was the supreme acting achievement of the entire year?  Surely Joan Allen's chilly portrayal of the icy, broken Pat Nixon displayed acting talent in spades.  Was Mira Sorvino really better than Joan Allen?  No...she was not. 
And the Oscar REALLY goes to: 
Joan Allen in Nixon.  Incidentally,  Marisa Tomei gets unfairly lumped in this category of undeserving Best Supporting Actress winner, I think.  In 1992, her win for her hilarious performance in My Cousin Vinny has held up through the years and has proven to be, indeed, worthy of much praise.  She has also subsequently given several memorable performances, such as In the Bedroom.



Best Actress, 1940:  Ginger Rogers in Kitty Foyle
Boy, was this one a head-scratcher!  The four other nominees gave performances that remain to this day in the "classic" category.  Ginger, er, not so much:

  • Bette Davis in The Letter
  • Joan Fontaine in Rebecca
  • Katharine Hepburn in The Philadelphia Story
  • Martha Scott Our Town
It's almost anti-American to knock the darling Ginger Rogers, but I find this film pretty much unwatchable.  Seeing her do her cutesy, little-girl routine makes me very, very nervous.  I really couldn't find an adequate explanation of how on earth she won the Oscar that year.  A true Oscar mystery. 
And the Oscar REALLY goes to: 
 Joan Fontaine in Rebecca.


Best Actress, 1947:  Loretta Young in The Farmer’s Daughter
(see above).  Another 1940's Oscar puzzlement.  Loretta Young was a stalwart, hard-working Hollywood veteran who had been making films since she was 12 years old.  And there were very few lovelier actresses than her.  But her phony-baloney Swedish accent was certainly not the thing for which Oscars should be given.  The most deserving performance that year lost out as it was in a little-seen, little-understood film called Mourning Becomes Electra.  The lead actress gives a "take-no-prisoners," full-out performance that was certainly leagues ahead of the Farmer's Daughter fluff.  I think viewers/voters were simply put-off/confused by the title and stayed away from it.  And the Oscar REALLY goes to:

Rosalind Russell in Mourning Becomes Electra.





Best Film, 1952:  The Greatest Show On Earth, Cecil B. De Mille's turgid tale of love and deceit behind the canvas curtain of the circus world is generally considered by Oscarologists (I just made up that term) to be the biggest "HUH?" choice of "Best Picture" in Oscar history (though Crash is rapidly rising in the ranks as the years expose its hollowness).
And the Oscar REALLY goes to: 

Singin in the Rain...which wasn't even NOMINATED!!


And, finally, the most egregiously idiotic award ever given by the Academy:



Best Song, 2006:  "It's Hard Out Here For a Pimp," from Hustle and Flow by Three 6 Mafia.  What is there to say?


And the Oscar REALLY goes to:  NO ONE!  Because this category should have been eliminated altogether atleast 15 years ago.


See:  Hmmm...where do we begin? for more on the "Best Song" category.

Also see: 

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

You MUST give back that Oscar! (Part 5)



In a similar vein as our previous choice of Grace Kelly over Judy Garland, our next selectee for "Most Undeserved Oscar" award is more about who didn't win, rather than who, in fact, won.  We're talking this time about the 1996 Best Supporting Actor winner, Cuba Gooding Jr. in Jerry Maguire.  It was Gooding's first and only nomination (to date).

b1779525.jpg
The English Patient:  This was as compelling as things got...


There was something seriously askew that year, as far as who/what won the big awards.  The big winner of 1996 was The English Patient, which clocks in at nearly 2 3/4 hours long...and seems MUCH longer than that; makes the old "watching paint dry" scenario seem positively alluring by comparison.  While it's not a classic "bad" film, it is a typical choice of Academy voters trying to prove that they have high-toned "taste".  It's British, it's stultifyingly dull, it has pretty scenery....it must be Fine Cinema! The characters are not particularly likable, and the flashbacks and interweaving of several plots require some serious concentration...which is hard to do when you're sound asleep.  Yes, it won nine Oscars that year, making it one of the winningest films of all time (tied for 3rd place for most wins, along with two other films).  If you Google "most boring movie of all time english patient," there are 87,400 results...make of that what you will.  One of the other nominees that year has gone on to achieve cult status as one of the most finely-crafted "black comedies" of all time:  The Coen Brothers instant classic, Fargo, which only won two awards that year (Frances McDormand most deservedly won Best Actress and the Coens won for Best Original Screenplay).
 

William H. Macy, for his brilliant portrayal of the befuddled, inept Jerry Lundegaard, went Oscarless.  Why?  For some reason, he was bafflingly placed in the "Best Supporting Actor" category.  Supporting?  Who was he "supporting"?  The plot revolved completely around his character and he would most surely be considered the "leading man".  It seems clear that Fargo's producers figured that Geoffrey Rush had a lock on the "Best Actor" that year for his brilliant performance in Shine, so they'd take their chances by placing Macy in the supporting category.  Big mistake.  Academy voters weren't fooled by the deception and, apparently, decided to vote otherwise.


Which brings us to Oscar Night, 1996.  The nominees for Best Supporting Actor were:
  • James Woods in Ghosts of Mississippi
  • William H. Macy in Fargo
  • Armin Mueller-Stahl in Shine
  • Edward Norton in Primal Fear
  • Cuba Gooding Jr. in Jerry Maguire
The presenter was the previous year's Best Supporting Actress winner, Mira Sorvino (see upcoming Part 6 of this series...) "And the Oscar goes to.....CUBA GOODING JR., JERRY MAGUIRE".  A clearly ecstatic Gooding leapt to the stage and delivered a heartfelt, if unnervingly antic acceptance speech, in which he professed his love for every single person he'd ever met. 
d7742b2c.jpg











Which is all fine...but HE DIDN'T DESERVE IT!  Jerry Maguire is an entertaining-enough "chick flick," with just enough sports-interest to make it an acceptable "date flick".  It was certainly popular, ringing up over $100 million at the box office.  Gooding does lend his character, a mercurial NFL wide receiver named "Rod Tidwell" much likability; in fact, in another, less-competent actor's hands, the character could have been simply obnoxious.  His most famous line almost instantly leapt into the American lexicon:  "SHOW ME THE MONEY!"  Fine, fine, fine....he was just fine.  But this was not an "Oscar-worthy" performance, especially when held up against Macy's great, multi-layered portrayal.  In addition to Macy, the young Edward Norton delivered a frightening, powerhouse performance opposite Richard Gere in Primal Fear.  By nearly anyone's standards, Norton's performance far outshone the manic emotings of Gooding. 





Since that year, Cuba Gooding Jr. has made almost 40 films--and scanning the list, one is left noggin-scratching at the obscurity of nearly all of the titles. Again, looking at the subsequent roles he's chosen, his most famous line, "Show me the money!" may have been his overriding creed when choosing his roles.

Cuba Gooding Jr.:  YOU MUST GIVE BACK THAT OSCAR!


And the Oscar REALLY goes to:  William H. Macy in Fargo


Also see:

Sunday, February 20, 2011

You MUST Give Back that Oscar! (Part 4)


The #4 selection in our parade of Oscar injustices may not be a popular one, and it's not a choice that  reflects on the ineptitude of the performance; rather for the performance that was not awarded that year.  The year was 1954.  The winner:  Grace Kelly in The Country Girl.  Kelly was at the beginning of her brief, meteoric career in Hollywood, before she gave it all up to become Princess Grace of Monaco.  She quickly ascended to the Hollywood "A-list" to become the co-star of such major stars as Clark Gable (Mogambo) and Gary Cooper (High Noon), among others.  1954 also marked the year of the comeback of Hollywood's most troubled, yet greatly beloved star, Judy Garland, in the first film remake of the perennial A Star Is Born (version #4 is currently in the works, to star Beyonce...uh huh).  Garland had had a much publicized crack-up, having been fired by MGM, had several suicide attempts, stays in mental institutions, etc.  As everyone knows, we all love a good comeback, and Garland (and her then-husband, Sid Luft) pulled out all the stops to ensure that her comeback would be a success.  Warner Brothers produced a lavish, color, wide-screen, big budget musical extravaganza that was the perfect showcase for Garland's many talents.  


And dazzlingly brilliant she was.  Not only her musical numbers, but her many wide-ranging dramatic scenes reveal her to be a truly great actress, delivering one of the most unforgettably vivid performances in cinema history. But at 196 minutes, A Star is Born was far too long for Warners' liking--following the bottom line that at that length, the number of times they could show it per day was reduced; thus, it was randomly and viciously slashed to a more fiscally palatable 154 minutes, rendering the film choppy, hard to follow and confusing (what's more, most of the cut footage was destroyed!).  And these cuts happened while the film was already in wide release, which left audiences feeling "gypped". It was one of the biggest mistakes Warner Brothers ever made.  But when the film was originally released, in its full length, Judy Garland was considered a shoo-in--and a much-deserved one, too--for the Best Actress Oscar.

The Country Girl was the filmed version of the Clifford Odets' Broadway hit, and starred Bing Crosby, as the washed-up, alcoholic singer/actor (in a subtle, effective performance).  And  in a bit of off-beat casting, they cast the gorgeous, glamourous Grace Kelly as his bitter, frumpish wife.  Her performance was just fine--and it wasn't her fault that she was far too young to play this role.  There's nothing embarassing about her performance, though one is left to wonder how much more effectively the part might have been played by an actress of a bit more "depth"--not to mention, age-appropriateness (Bette Davis, perhaps?). 



So, it's Oscar night.  Judy Garland is not in attendance, as she is in Cedars of Lebanon hospital in Los Angeles, having just given birth to her only son, Joey.  But her "lock" on the Best Actress category was so assured, the producers of the Academy Awards that year actually set up scaffolding outside the window of Garland's hospital room, in order to beam her acceptance speech, via remote, to the worldwide television audience (the show was televised for the first time only the year before).  Garland later recalled that when Kelly's name was announced as the winner, the television crew silently began dismantling their lights and scaffolding and wordlessly scurried out of her hospital room.  A heartbreaking scenario, to say the least.


There was a huge hue and cry in Hollywood (and beyond) over the injustice of the Academy's choice.  Groucho Marx famously quipped that it was the "greatest robbery since Brink's".  It became clear that it was something of a voter revolt against Warner Brothers for their greedy mutilation of a brilliant film, for  A Star is Born was completely shut out of  any major awards, receiving only one award, period:  For Best Original Musical Score.  George Cukor's flawless direction and Moss Hart's magnificent script (which stands up against any script of any year), weren't even nominated--nor was the film itself.  And furthermore--in what was perhaps more a matter of "bad timing," James Mason (who was nominated) lost the Best Actor award to Marlon Brando's deserving performance in On the Waterfront--though I still feel Mason's heartbreaking, multi-layered portrayal of the lost Norman Maine should have won).


Painstaking efforts to try to track down the excised footage from the original version of the 1954 A Star is Born have been underway for decades, and scenes and snippets continue to turn up.  But the version that is most commonly shown and is available on DVD is sort of a mutilated beauty; a shadow of what Cukor and Hart's vision must have been, with scenes recreated using still photographs.  It's sad to see this glimpse of "what might have been," it's all we've got (for now?).

Grace Kelly's victory that year is generally considered by most Oscar historians to be one of the greatest injustices in the history of the Oscars.  It's one in a long line of performances that were deemed Oscar-worthy, by glamourgirl actresses who won the award for taking off their makeup (Jane Wyman for Johnny Belinda; Sophia Loren, Two Women; Charlize Theron for Monster, to name a few) .  Principality of Monaco: 
You MUST give back that Oscar!  Send it to Liza, or something  Here is, perhaps, Judy Garland's finest scene in this very fine film.  And, incredibly, this is one of the scenes that the hatchet-men at Warner Brothers deemed unnecessary and cut from the final print.  Fortunately, it somehow escaped being destroyed, as so many others ultimately were. 

See also:     

Saturday, February 12, 2011

You Must Give Back That Oscar! (Part 2)

Continuing our list of performers/directors/producers who, in the light of a new century, it is clearly revealed that they were presented with an Oscar in error and that they must give them back!  Our first false-recipient, Roberto Benigni, has still not contacted The Academy about returning his awards for Life Is Beautiful.  Roberto, it's not too late to resolve this issue before Oscar-time...    Our second one would be the producer/director/writer of the 2005 dogshow, Crash, which shockingly won the award that year for "Best Picture".  What in the hell happened that year?  For only the second time in the history of the Academy Awards, Crash was given the Best Picture award, even though it wasn't even nominated for the Golden Globe for Best Picture.  The front-runner for Best Picture that year was the critically-acclaimed gay-themed drama, Brokeback Mountain.  In a major upset victory, Crash was named the winner, leaving millions of jaws dropped and heads scratched.
Crash:  About as subtle as a "dirty" nuclear device...


Though it was an all-star (Sandra Bullock, Matt Dillon, Brendan Fraser, etc.), multi-layered interweaving of several stories (sounds good so far, right?), Crash lives up to its title before the end of the first reel.  Written, directed and produced by Paul Haggis (at the time, one of the most prominent Hollywood Scientologists--he has since very publicly renounced his membership with the religion/cult), this film is painted with such a broad brush as to almost seem a cartoon, or at the very least, a parody.  He tries to intermesh several tales of racial prejudice and hatred in modern day Los Angeles into one cohesive whole, but it soon unravels into a muddled pile of stereotypes, highly implausible situations and near-miraculous coincidences.  Nearly all the characters in the film are loathesome and one is left wishing they'd all just shoot each other already and be done with it.  It'd be too easy to say it's a "Crash"-ing bore...because I certainly wasn't bored;  I was too angry to be bored, having just shelled out 10 bucks, only to be manipulated by a preachy, unbalanced, transparently false mess of a film.  
 

I saw the film before the Oscars and hated it then.  Then, after it swept the awards that year, I was completely dumbfounded that so many Americans could be fooled into believing that something this incompetent was worthy of being elected to a top prize--then I realized that George W. Bush had just been reelected for a 2nd term in office and it all became clear to me.  It seemed to me that the Conservative Right of the American Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences was not about to vote for "no homo movie" for "Best Picture," which greased the skids for Crash to win by default.

Crash is an amateurish, insincere and disingenuous film that is highly unworthy of "best" anything!  Paul Haggis:  YOU MUST GIVE BACK YOUR AWARDS! (he won for Best Screenplay, too!).  While you're at it, could you round up the jokers who won the "Best Song" Oscar that year and tell them to haul back their Oscars, too?  I'm not saying "It's Hard Out Here For a Pimp" is a bad song, but.....

And the actual recipient of the Best Picture of 2005 is:

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

You must GIVE BACK THAT OSCAR! (Part 1)

Everyone makes mistakes now and then....ESPECIALLY the American Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences.  Through the years, one will notice some shocking errors, which can only be blamed on the tenor of the times, shameless campaigning on the part of the studios and/or the performer involved....or could it be a simple miscount on the part of Price-Waterhouse?  In any event, as we count down toward this year's Academy Awards (February 27th) we are going to highlight five examples of these shameful errors on the part of the Academy and are putting out a request for the person(s) involved to simply and quietly return their mistakenly-awarded Oscar to the Academy....no questions asked.  Let us begin:


1998:  Roberto Benigni, Life Is Beautiful (La vita รจ bella)


Perhaps inspired by Jerry Lewis and his legendary, unfinished disaster, The Day the Clown Cried (Lewis's self-written/directed/acted film about a clown in a concentration camp during World War II), the previously unknown (in America), Roberto Benigni wrote, directed and starred in this dreadful, false tale that seemed to fool critics and audiences alike into thinking that this dreck was "art".  It isn't.  It uses the Holocaust as a cheap cinematic device, completely trivializing the horrors of war while hiding behind the veil of being "a fable".  It rings false at nearly every turn, and Benigni's Italo-campy antics get annoying after roughly 2 1/2 minutes.  The film won the "Grand Prize of the Jury" at the Cannes Film Festival that year and went on to win the "Best Foreign Language Film" at the 1998 Academy Awards.  Benigni, in an unprecedentedly tacky display, walked on the backs of the auditorium seats and then proceeded to bunny-hop up the aisle, while receiving a huge standing ovation (his first of two that night).  He then launched into a babbling acceptance speech that made absolutely no sense...even compatriot Sophia Loren, who presented the award, looked utterly baffled.

Then it came time for the "Best Actor" award.  It was a tight race that year, with most money riding on either Edward Norton for American History X or Ian McKellan for Gods and Monsters, with Benigni considered an unlikely winner.  But when Helen Hunt (her name may be coming up later in this list....) opened the envelope, there he was again.  More standing ovation.  More crazed antic babbling.  


The years have not been kind to Life is Beautiful.  For me, if ever there was a film that screams "lost something in translation," this is the one.  Its forced, contrived sentimentality at the expense of those who actually endured the Holocaust--who would no doubt unanimously agree that there were no moments of jolly antics--is utterly painful to watch.  And Benigni's double-caffeinated, soppy Pagliacci performance is most certainly not of award-winning caliber.  Give them back, Roberto.  Give them both back, and we'll just pretend it didn't happen, okay?  Grazie....
And the award actually goes to: 

Edward Norton, American History X